After Xavi

Is it time for Spain to phase out their most important player?
Share |

The prologue of Inverting the Pyramid, Jonathan Wilson’s magisterial history of soccer tactics, begins with a drunken argument in a bar in Portugal following England’s 3-0 victory over Switzerland at Euro 2004. A spirited (and spirit-aided) debate erupts when a British journalist argues that England’s tactical formation had nothing to do with the result, and that only the players fielded matters when considering the outcome of a match. This comment inspires an admittedly soused Wilson to accuse his colleague of soccer philistinism. Thinking she has come to Wilson’s rescue, an Argentinean colleague interrupts the spat to tell the British journalist that, on the contrary, formation is the only variable of consequence in soccer. While largely agreeing with his Argentine colleague, Wilson cautions that these either/or opinions expressed by his peers regarding tactics or personnel obscure a more important truism: if you don’t have players to make the system work then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter.

This lesson seems especially relevant when considering Spain’s recent defeat to Brazil in the Confederations Cup final. To be sure, the long and medium terms look rosy for the Spanish. They’ve captured the last two U-21 European titles, lost on penalties to Brazil in a U-20 World Cup knockout round match they dominated two years ago and put together a string of impressive performances before going out in extra-time in the quarterfinals to Uruguay in the same tournament several weeks ago. Furthermore, many if not most soccer pundits have expressed caution about writing Spain off on account of one result. Some also cite mitigating factors like Spanish fatigue and Brazilian home field advantage in a tournament with far less away spectators than a World Cup will offer. Nevertheless, as the Guardian’s Paul Doyle wrote in his post-match edition of “The Fiver,” Spain’s “defeat was so comprehensive that expressing doubts about their system and personnel is no longer enough to identify a person … as an ignorant crank.”

If nothing else, the loss to Brazil signaled that Spain are at a critical juncture in terms of their prospects for the senior World Cup next summer. Several issues they face reflect the central dilemma pointed out in Wilson’s prologue: tactics or personnel? Or more specific, given the current tactical trends and the likely strategies to be employed by Spain’s nearest rivals (Brazil, Germany, and Italy), what tweaks in personnel and tactics should be made to defend their title?

At the heart of this concern is Xavi Hernandez, the player who has defined Spain and Barcelona’s five years of nearly uninterrupted success, and arguably the man who more so than any other in the modern era has defined a single soccer style – tiki-taka, which is based on the constant creation of passing triangles, possession soccer, and aggressive defensive pressing. Xavi is what Sid Lowe has called the team’s key ideologue – a player who himself is representative of the relationship between players and systems – virtually a system unto himself. It wasn’t long ago that for these very reasons I wrote that Xavi deserved the Ballon d’Or awarded to the best player in Europe. But at risk of being accused of apostasy, Spain’s short-term fortunes might hinge on whether theirs and Barcelona’s midfield maestro accepts certain tactical requirements, regains optimal fitness, or retires from international soccer.

There was something breathtakingly gruesome about the manner in which Brazil swept aside Spain. Like hobbits being overrun by a cavalry of orcs, Spain couldn’t compete physically with Brazil’s mostly fair tackling and rapid counter-attacks. The ease in which Brazil was able to attack at pace between Spain’s midfield and defensive lines suggested both tactical and player dilemmas for La Roja: holding midfielder Sergio Busquets couldn’t by himself cover the space flooded by the Brazilian attackers in the final third, while the distance between Spain’s midfield and defense when they lost the ball meant Brazil often had unusually favorable numbers in attack, which explains why Spanish defenders often resorted to cynical last-ditch tackles. Apart from formation, the more robust Brazilian midfield consistently outmuscled Spain’s sprightly creators for the ball and attacked with a scalpel sharpness that did not so much substitute the stylish for the pragmatic as it made the pragmatic look stylish. There were shades of the Bayern Munich-Barcelona Champions League semi-final, which inspired Michael Cox to argue that German clubs are producing a winning blend of “intensity and intricacy” while the Spanish rely too much on precision.

Indeed, the impressive depth that we normally associate with Spain has to do with the staggering number of diminutive world-class number 10s (media punta) at their disposal: Xavi, Andres Iniesta, David Silva, Juan Mata, Santi Cazorla, and Cesc Fabregas, not to mention aspiring senior-side players such as the impish Isco, who recently signed for Real Madrid, and the Bayern Munich-bound Barcelona product Thiago Alcantara. Spanish manager Vicente del Bosque’s decision to include so many players of a similar type in his squad is possibly reflective of a deep commitment to the style that brought Spain so much success. It’s also emblematic of a distinctive Spanish culture of soccer that has been developing since the late 1980s that prioritizes touch, vision, and creativity irrespective of physical size — soccer’s version of “small ball.”

In a fascinating article on Spain’s integration of the number 10, Jimmy Areabi explains that the Spanish national team has traditionally been defined by the culture of soccer of the Basque region of Spain, which took its cues from Britain in emphasizing passion, power, and pace. Things began to change with the import of large numbers of Latin American players in the 1970s – particularly Argentineans – who filled the creative midfield roles for many clubs in La Liga. The more crucial moment, however, came in 1988 when the legendary Johan Cryuff returned to Barcelona as manager, reconstituted the youth training facilities, and implemented a Dutch system of development based on possession soccer and a fluid 4-3-3 system. In his book Barca: The Making of the Greatest Team in the World, Graham Hunter tells us that fan culture at the Camp Nou prior to Cruyff’s tenure as manager was such that fans jeered and whistled if the ball wasn’t booted forward from defense quickly enough. The success of Cruyff’s tactical revolution eventually won fans over, as did the Dutchman’s integration of several Catalan youth players to the first team, particularly a young, slow-footed, reed-thin deep-lying playmaker by the name of Pep Guardiola. His visionary exploits at the base of Barca’s midfield would serve as the inspiration for the likes of Xavi, Iniesta, and Fabregas, who emulated their predecessor in terms of both style and commitment to playing a particular brand of soccer based on the intelligent use of space. While Barcelona’s template and players have always influenced the way the Spanish national team plays, this current incarnation more than any other took them as its model, with Barcelona players making up between six and eight starters during the Confederations Cup. More critically, Spain’s midfield was identical to Barcelona’s first-choice trio of Xavi, Iniesta, and Busquets. Those who argue that the Brazil game was a one-off miss a fundamental point, which is that a very similar Barcelona team was undone in very similar fashion by Bayern Munich and a fast and athletic Real Madrid in the second half of the season.

Spain, however, have the kinds of players necessary to compete physically with the world’s more athletic sides. In our awe of Spain’s chorus line of nimble creators, we tend to forget that they have produced world-class players at other positions who offer more varied skill sets. Consider Bayern Munich’s box-to-box power midfielder Javi Martinez, who was central to Barcelona’s undoing in the Champions League; Juventus’s battering ram center forward Fernando Llorente; Manchester City’s turbocharged classic winger Jesus Navas; and even Fabregas, who, as his Barcelona teammates and coaches often point out, offers something more anarchic and direct than the typical Spanish playmaker. Details aside, Spain have the personnel to play a more varied tactical game based around the brawn and technical intricacy we now associate with the best German clubs (and, as of the conclusion of the Confederations Cup, the Brazilian national team) without necessarily sacrificing the measured control they exhibit in their best moments.

This brings us to other tactical considerations. The double pivot of two holding midfielders in a 4-2-3-1 formation that made so many Anglo-American spectators and pundits complain of a boring Spanish style was replaced by a 4-3-3 formation with one holding midfielder due to an injury to Xabi Alonso, which meant that Spain were more exciting but more open as well. While the this most recent tournament offered a period of competitive experimentation with a three-man midfield, the degree to which it was bypassed by Brazil, Italy, and even Nigeria suggest it’s perhaps time for del Bosque to part with the experiment. If Xabi Alonso cannot be counted on for either physical or personal reasons, del Bosque should consider pairing the more dynamic Javi Martinez with Busquets. Busquets’s lateral movement and ability to anticipate and breakup attacks has earned him the nickname “the Octopus of Badia” (which is either the current best or worst sports nickname), while Martinez’s boundless energy has prompted Adidas to include the big Basque in their lineup of “Engine” players who cover the most ground per match according to Opta statistics. What Spain will lose in Xabi Alonso’s range of passing they gain in defensive cover and speed on the break — Martinez in particular bounds forward with great vigor — which will be more important as more teams lose their fear of being picked apart and push forward to attack Spain.

At the heart of these tactical personnel considerations is Xavi, who through success, force of personality, and slow but sure decline as a player has emerged as the single most important variable concerning Spain’s short term fortunes. As Sid Lowe’s postmortem article on Spain’s immediate outlook points out, Spain and Barcelona must plan for a future without their co-captain, or at very least ensure that his conditioning regime is such that he is able to turn up in big games fully fit. Not all of this is directly Xavi’s fault, as a chronic Achilles tendon problem has hampered his ability to snap into tackles when pressing and made him slightly more ponderous offensively. But the Xavi issue transcends questions of fitness. Though del Bosque has played down rifts with the Barcelona legend, if rumors are to be believed, one of the reasons Spain played with only one holding midfielder is that Xavi strongly suggested they do so. His preferred position is slightly deeper, where he sees more of the ball. At Barca, Xavi starts closer to the center circle, gradually tiki-takas his way up the pitch, stops somewhere around the penalty area and sometimes ghosts into the box to score goals. This is fine when he is playing in a 4-3-3, but in a 4-2-3-1 he is the middle of the line of three advanced midfielders much closer to the forward line, where he gets fewer touches and is much less effective. (There were even rumblings last summer about dropping Xavi for a player more comfortable playing in the final third of the field.) Either way, he is less happy and less effective in a system that — it must be repeated — yielded a European championship and World Cup. If returning to a double pivot is a nonstarter for Xavi, his place in the first team ought to be questioned.

This suggestion is not meant to demean his place in history. Lowe’s characterization of Xavi as Spanish football’s chief ideologue was not meant to be derogatory. In fact, given the tremendous amount of success spearheaded by him for his club and national team, it was probably meant as a compliment. He is a player that almost breaks down the dichotomy between players and tactics. It’s slightly too early to tell if Spain and Barca’s success is coming to an end of a cycle, but it would do no harm to emphasize that Xavi is more than a card-carrying member to Cruyff’s finishing school; he is a zealot defender of the faith. If systemic changes, as modest as they may be, need to be made for next summer’s World Cup, Spain would do well to remember that zealots rarely do well as innovators. 


Share |

Comments

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!Egyptian Cotton Towels Uk

which side we were on the moment we entered the Grand Garden Arena, with Brazilian or U.S. flags being handed out to everyone .. viagra bestellen

work then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter. http://www.textyourexbackforum.com/

I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good smart happy birthday wishes

then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter. click here

shitting away fan goodwill is one of Vincent Kennedy McMahon's favorite activities. And so it was on Sunday night.Acne No More Website

Wishing you the good luck for all your blogging endeavors. I went over this site a long time back yet I've just barely chosen to stop back and have a perused of your articles. watkins solicitors bristol

work then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter. CobyBingo

I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't for more wait to read lots of your posts

then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter. car hire st lucia

Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing. kettlebell workout

She always want to get more and share more knowledge about these fields. Enjoy her articles. everlast

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comment teak chairs

I love your posts! if you need a crystal x article on women's health we offer the best solutions and guaranteed 100% treat female problems visit also here to refer to the article bumble bee removal

We Are A Full-Service Provider Of High Quality Backlinks That Help Boost Traffic, Increase Rankings, And Build Authority. With Years Of Experience We Know Exactly What Type Of Manual Dofollow Blog Comments It Takes To Quickly Increase Your Online Visibility
High PR Links

Thanks a lot for sharing this amazing knowledge with us. This site is fantastic. I always find great knowledge from it http://www.caaom.org

I think I should also work hard for my own website like I see some good and updated working in your site.Free Ebook Downloads

I would never have thought of on my own. Your content gives readers things to think about in an interesting way. Thank you for your clear information....unlocked cell phone

I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues. Backlinks

Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comment High pr Links

I couldn't come across to much additional information on this piece, so it was pleasant to locate this one. I will certainly end up being back again to check out some other posts that you have another time...

webdesign

You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site Satılık müzik seti kablosu

oved here today why you are one of the best in this business. Continue to dazzle me with your work, ma.. Link building service

In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own Blog Engine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.dynamic web design

make the system work then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter.sash windows london

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates. emlak bayiliği veren firmalar

I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike other blogs I have read which are really not that good.Thanks alot! is your phone unlocked

been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. .. PDFs Directory

I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post opt in email blast

f you don’t implement tactics that get the visit website
best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter..

I have some true tangles depicting my pondering on substance; regardless I emphatically felt I ought to here. Your Fat cow coupon article is genuinely unimaginable. I like the way you made this data.rebelmouse.com

I located this blog! From time to time, students want to cognitive the keys of productive literary essays composing. Your first-class knowledge about this good post can become a proper basis for such people. ..old school new body John Rowley and Steve

I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantastic lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.residential property management software

I wish more authors of this type of content would take the time you did to research and write so well. cialis generico

would take the time you did to research and write so well.. Free PDF Ebooks Directory

You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site. email opt in marketing

I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.whatsapp status quotes

I have bookmarked this site page for my not so distant reference. Much obliged once more after additional.online degree programs

It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues. divorce advice

Barcelona team was undone in very similar fashion by Bayern Munich and a fast and athletic Real Madrid in the second half of the season.gt avalanche 3.0

defined by 36 points and showed that one could be satisfied with the fit of a 30 term model:textyourexbackmichaelfiore.com/2012/michael-fiore-text-your-ex-back-examples

But at risk of being accused of apostasy, Spain’s short-term fortunes might hinge on whether theirs and Barcelona’s midfield maestro accepts certain tactical requirements, regains optimal fitness, or retires from international soccer.Friendship SMS

I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!! historical racing in idaho

then tactics don’t matter, and if you don’t implement tactics that get the best out the players, personnel doesn’t matter. https://www.rebelmouse.com/

This lesson seems especially relevant when considering Spain’s recent defeat to Brazil in the Confederations Cup final. To be sure, the long and medium terms look rosy for the Spanish. mario games

Its as if you had a great grasp on the subject matter, but you forgot to include your readers. Perhaps you should think about this from more than one angle.internet marketing

the heel of the outer boot must be at least one boot length, measured in the direction of the ski. amazing selling machine

Much obliged to you for your imparting. I have bookmarked this site page for my not so distant reference ,. Ebooks Library

Thanks For sharing this Superb article.I use this Article to show my assignment in college.it is useful For me Great Work. http://www.stockbroker-career.com/

the bathroom in the middle of a match? What will the fans be like? Will the matches be different from the ones waterproof matches